Geothermal energy for powergen “could save the world,” but it isn’t getting enough attention, a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) director said on March 19.
“Communication and education have been something that have been thought of as secondary … and I think that's hurt geothermal,” Lauren Boyd, DOE director, geothermal technologies office, said at CERAWeek by S&P Global.
But “we have a variety of incredible technologies that can save the world included in this bucket, this family” of energy technologies.
For those who understand it, the investment hurdle is in the subsurface risk. “Who's actually working on next-generation geothermal are the startups,” said Irlan Amir, geothermal director for energy-services firm SLB.
As for power producers, “they're looking into geothermal but they're not comfortable because the subsurface risk is too high for them,” Amir said. “They don't know [the risk assessment]. They're not comfortable. They're very good in power generation or power plant technologies.
“But the subsurface? They're not comfortable.”
Environmental risks include the potential for earthquakes and sinkholes — and steam that contains H2S and ammonia as well as elements such as mercury.
Then there’s the geologic risk, which is assessed much like in oil and gas drilling. Curtis Cook, founder and CEO of Calgary-based geothermal startup Rodatherm Energy, told Hart Energy after the CERAWeek session that subsurface risk in geothermal includes the economic life of the well.
As with oil and gas development, acreage consists of Tier 1, Tier 2 and fringe areas. While geothermal is fairly ubiquitous, some spots are sweeter than others in terms of heat intensity and the EUR of each well.
Some wells may be dry holes.
But “geothermal is and can be competitive,” Ajit Menon, vice president, geothermal, for Baker Hughes, said during the session.
The clean nature of the energy source should be considered by users, he said. “If you have a clean base load, will it have premium pricing over intermittent [power, such as wind and solar]? What’s the value to the end user?”
Menon added some states are factoring into their thinking that geothermal is essentially its own storage tank as they weigh it against wind and solar. With that additional measure, “it becomes very good” as an option, Menon said.
Well costs can be high due to cementing, Boyd said. But “if we're valuing geothermal appropriately, then it is extremely worthwhile.”
Greg Leveille, former CTO for ConocoPhillips, asked the panelists when geothermal wells will be longer and deeper than the half-mile verticals and laterals he has seen.
“When we started out in [the] Barnett [Shale], they were 3,000 feet in length. Today we're drilling 15,000 feet. The amount of production we get out of a 15,000-footer is significantly more than 3,000,” Leveille said.
Baker Hughes’ Menon said that “longer laterals are going to deliver much more performance. I think the [geothermal] players are all looking at that.”
Another advancement would be in a larger hole size, he said. “That could be a game changer.”
SLB’s Amir concurred. “That's the next step where this thing needs to go—a longer lateral with a big hole size,” he said. “I think pushing that beyond 3,000 to 5,000 to 10,000 [feet] is a goal. Absolutely.”
Another attendee asked if there may be tax breaks for geothermal dry holes, just as there are for oil and gas dry holes. The DOE’s Boyd said she isn’t aware of such incentives for geothermal.
Menon said there used to be a program. “In fact, it stimulated a lot of activity on the West Coast where dry exploration costs were subsidized. Internationally, I think Iceland is still doing that.”
Generally, he added, he’s seen that tax breaks on dry holes have incented geothermal exploration and development in the past.
Recommended Reading
Gunvor Group Inks Purchase Agreement with Texas LNG Brownsville
2024-03-19 - The agreement with Texas LNG Brownsville calls for a 20-year free on-board sale and purchase agreement of 0.5 million tonnes per annum of LNG for a Gunvor Group subsidiary.
CERAWeek: LNG to Play Critical Role in Shell's Future, CEO Says
2024-03-19 - Sawan said LNG will continue to play a critical role adding that LNG currently makes up around 13% of gas sales but was expected to grow to around 20% in the coming 15 to 20 years.
CoolCo, GAIL Enter Long-term LNG Agreement
2024-05-16 - CoolCo and GAIL’s agreement is intended to secure long-term LNG supply in India’s market, with GAIL having an option to extend the 14-year agreement by another two years.
Sempra Targets Summer 2025 for Commercial Start of ECA LNG Phase 1
2024-03-06 - Sempra is targeting the summer of 2025 as the commercial operations date for its 3.25 mtpa (0.43 Bcf/d) nameplate capacity Energía Costa Azul LNG Phase 1 project, located in Ensenada in Baja California, Mexico.
NextDecade Targets Second Half of 2024 for Phase 2 FID at Rio Grande LNG
2024-03-13 - NextDecade updated its progress on Phase 1 of the Rio Grande LNG facility and said it is targeting a final investment decision on two additional trains in the second half of 2024.